Trading vs Investing: Which is best for you?

People who are new to trading or investing have numerous questions and concerns in mind. One of the most common thoughts is whether to profit from the stock market by trading or investing.

Why not?

Trading and investing both sound similar but are actually different. Each of these terms comes with its own set of risks and benefits. Knowing the difference between trading vs investing is essential to move forward.

So, in this blog, we will discuss the potential differences and similarities between stock trading and investing, helping you decide the best for you!

Trading vs Investing

What is Trading?

Trading is a short-term process of buying and selling commodities, stocks, derivatives, currencies, or other financial stuff. The primary goal is to profit by taking advantage of short-term price changes. Hence, traders take advantage of market volatility by frequently buying and selling stuff.

They also assess the opportunities using charts and trading systems, which help them determine when to enter or exit a trade. This is known as technical analysis.

Even though trading offers good liquidity and profits, traders must remember it’s risky. Hence, it’s not suitable for beginners, as with a slight mistake, they can easily lose money.

There are different types of trading – 

  • Position Trading – Traders buy and hold a stock for a few months, looking for best-selling opportunities.
  • Swing Trading – Traders buy and keep a stock for a few days or weeks, hoping to gain profits from upward market movement.
  • Day Trading – In this, traders buy stocks in the morning and sell them before the market closes on the same day. This approach is to make profits on a single-day perspective, caused by news or market sentiments of that day.
  • Scalp Trading – These traders buy and sell quickly, sometimes in just a few seconds or minutes. They try to make money from even the smallest price changes.

What is Investing?

Investing refers to a long-term approach to buying stocks or other financial stuff that generate profits over many years. It’s not a quick way to make money, and you need to be patient. People who invest hold onto the stuff they buy for a really long time, like years or even decades.

Also, buying the stocks and holding them for a long time makes investors a part of the company, and they can benefit from dividends, bonuses, buybacks, and stock splits. Even when the market goes up and down, investors believe they’ll make money in the long run.

Before investing, investors do a lot of research using fundamental analysis to find good stocks. They look at things like the price-to-earnings ratio and management history and identify the potential stock to invest in.

The idea is to create a portfolio of stocks that will increase in value over time. Unlike trading, investing doesn’t involve buying and selling all the time. It’s more about holding onto what you have, except in emergencies or when you reach your money goal. 

But here, too, investors must keep track of their investments as they are volatile, and any news or change may sometimes impact the stocks.

There are different types of investing – 

  • Value Investing – This is about ensuring your investment stays valuable and doesn’t lose too much money. Investors pick well-established companies, even though there might not be a lot of growth.
  • Growth Investing – This is about growing the value of your investments a lot. Investors pick stocks that have the potential to grow quickly. This comes with more risk but also a chance for more growth.

Read More: Mutual Funds vs PPF: Which is better form of investment

Difference Between Stock Trading and Investing

Difference between Stock Trading and Investing

Source: tradebrains

There are many differences between trading vs investing in India, and you can understand them with these factors below – 

1. Risk Involved

InvestingTrading
The approach is to buy stocks and hold them for a long time to grow the money.The idea is to buy and sell stocks quickly to make money from small price changes.
The risk is lower because investors don’t make quick decisions when the market is unpredictable or volatile.The risk is higher because traders try to make money from short-term changes that are hard to predict.
Investors hold onto their stocks for a long time, so short-term ups and downs in the market don’t affect them much.Traders use tricks like borrowing money (leverage); even small price changes can lead to big losses. If the price goes the wrong way and the trader hasn’t set a limit, it can be a big problem.

2. Period of Investment

InvestingTrading
Investing is like playing a long game, like a test match – the approach is to hold and grow your investment.
Trading is like playing a short game, similar to a T20 match in cricket – the approach is about making a small profit by buying and selling quickly.
The period of investment is usually long, and patience is required to achieve the target.The period of investment is short.
Some investors hold onto their stocks for years or many decades and stay patient even when the market goes through ups and downs.Traders don’t wait for a long time; they embrace the risk of market volatility – they might sell a stock in a few hours or maybe wait for a few weeks, but it’s not for many years like investing.

3. Capital Growth

InvestingTrading
Investing focuses on slowly growing your capital by holding on to it for the long term, minimizing the risk.Trading refers to focusing on making profits in the short term.
Investors aim to make profits not just by increasing their stocks’ value but also by getting extra goodies like dividends and bonus issues.Unlike investing, traders are not looking for long-term benefits like dividends. They prepare strategies and the right opportunities to execute their trades.
It’s a slow and patient process.Traders aim to grow their money fast by making smart moves every day. If they keep doing this over time, their capital can increase.

4. Efforts Involved

InvestingTrading
Investing needs a bit of work effort in analyzing stocks initially to invest in.Trading requires a lot of ongoing work. It’s like regularly analyzing and identifying the narrowest mispricings and market changes.
Once you’ve made your investment, you don’t need to put in a lot of effort regularly. You wait and watch your money grow.Trading involves looking at charts, finding patterns, and making quick decisions. It’s not a sit-back-and-relax kind of thing.
It’s not about constantly checking and making decisions. It’s more like making a good choice initially and then relaxing.The risk is high, so traders need to be super careful and smart.

5. Style of Analysis

InvestingTrading
Investing requires fundamental analysis.Trading requires technical analysis.
Fundamental analysis means looking at the company’s financial health, key ratios, balance sheets, and future growth possibilities.Technical analysis involves looking at charts, graphs, and past movements. Traders make decisions based on the patterns they see in these charts.
It’s about understanding the company’s story and determining if it will grow in the long run.It’s more about predicting short-term movements and making quick, smart moves.

Key Similarities

Stock Trading and Investing have one common goal – making profits.

Both traders and investors do this by opening accounts to buy and sell financial stuff like stocks, mutual funds, and bonds.

But both stock trading and investing have a mix of risk and reward. There are no sure things in markets. Every investment can give you big wins, but it can also mean losing money. The amount of risk might differ, but both offer chances for profits and losses.

Read Also: What is Share Market in India?

Who Should Invest, and Who Should Trade?

Firstly, it’s essential to know that both investing and trading are open to everyone. You don’t need fancy qualifications; you can learn and improve with time and practice.

Investing is super easy – anyone can start, even if you don’t know much about stocks. You just need to pick the right stock, invest using your Demat & Trading A/c, and keep an eye on it regularly.

On the other hand, trading needs a bit more skill than investing. You have to understand the charts and patterns of a share. Knowing about indicators and technical analysis is key for a trader. To make money in the stock market, a trader must learn these skills. It’s like leveling up in a game; the more you practice, the better you get.

Trading Wisely

If you’re thinking about trading, it’s important to be smart about it to reduce your risks. Here are some things to keep in mind – 

  • Make a Plan – Decide when to buy and sell. Maybe you sell if a stock goes up or down by a certain percentage. Having a plan helps you stay on track.
  • Stick to Your Plan – Even experienced traders sometimes change their minds. It’s crucial to stick to the plan you made.
  • Set a Limit – Determine the most money you can afford to lose, and don’t exceed that limit. It’s like having a budget for trading.
  • Stay Informed – On average, the stock market goes up by 10%. Even pros find it hard to beat the market. Know the facts before you start.
  • Understand Taxes – Trading can affect your taxes. You might get a deduction for trading costs but also owe taxes. Short-term gains can be taxed from 10% to 37%. Learn about short- and long-term capital gains.

Investing Wisely

Investing is a way to grow your money over time.

Here’s how to do it wisely –

  • Have a Plan – Decide when to buy, sell, and adjust your investments. If the market moves a lot, you might need to change your holdings to match your goals.
  • Consider Index Funds – These funds don’t try to beat the market. Instead, they follow the performance of a market index. It’s a more hands-off approach.
  • Know Your Strategy – Understand why you’re investing – maybe for retirement or college. Know how much risk you’re comfortable with.
  • Be Patient – Investing is for the long term. You need to be patient and stick with it, even when the market goes up and down.

Trading vs Investing – Which is better?

Trading vs Investing - Which is better?

source: motilaloswal

Though both stock trading and investing aim to make money, they have different strategies. However, trading can be riskier for a couple of reasons – 

  • Analysis and Forecasting – Trading requires a lot of analysis and predicting the future to make quick decisions. Unlike investing, where you can take your time, trading demands fast thinking.
  • Close Monitoring – Day traders who buy and sell within the same day must keep a close eye on their positions. They have to adjust things quickly. While trading can bring in profits quickly, it comes with risks.

Hence, if you’re comfortable with taking risks, trading might be for you. If you prefer less risk, investing might be a better fit.

If you wish to try both trading vs Investing in India, start with great knowledge. And to learn these, Upmarket Academy is a fantastic platform. It is one of the best stock market academies, offering valuable resources and insights about trading.

Explore Upmarket Academy’s courses to learn everything from the basics to advanced concepts of trading vs investing in India and boost your trading success.

So, if you’re eager to dive into the world of trading, this could be a great opportunity for you.

Stay in Touch

Subscribe for Latest Updates and Knowledge related to Stock Market

Related Articles